School libraries axed at cash-starved districts

At Natomas Unified School District, the school library has become a luxury that can't be afforded.

Library staff at eight elementary schools were laid off last week as district officials cordoned off their rooms with locks and chains, according to Sacramento Bee.

Flickr photo by bigteetoe

Natomas officials told the Bee the move could save up $1.5 million in salary and benefits. The district, which is grappling with a budget shortfall of $17.3 million, hopes to reopen the libraries when the budget improves, according to the Bee.

According to Heidi Van Zant, Natomas district spokeswoman:

"These kinds of cuts are a last resort. No one wants to close elementary school libraries, but our budget situation is so severe there was no choice."

The closed libraries mirror a larger trend of media centers falling from their once-valued perch in the education eco-system. Last month, Elk Grove Unified issued final layoff notices to about 57 library staffers. Folson Cordova Unified shuttered its libraries last summer but reopened them with reduced hours after extracting salary concessions from the teachers' union. Corona-Norco, Las Virgenes and Lompoc school districts have similarly laid off their school library personnel.

In March 2009, the Modesto school district cut its library staff just after it received a $509,000 grant for training and buying supplies. Now, only two librarians cover the district's four junior highs, and nine are split among 23 elementary campuses, according to the Modesto Bee.

The long-term impact of such decisions have yet to be realized.

But one wonders about the wisdom of eliminating librarians and walling off books, magazines and computers from growing young minds. Listen to this once unthinkable comment from Ramneek Kaur, a fourth grader at Natomas Unified's Bannon Creek Elementary.

We used to have dance and art. Now, no books. All that is left is PE."

Ironically, gym may be next on the school budget chopping block.

Filed under: K–12, Daily Report

Comments

Comments are closed for this story.
SubmitguRu's picture
This is terrible news. What happen with education now ? Or this is political order ? California Dating
sraslim's picture
These districts just have no common sense. Yes, cuts need to be made. Yes, tough decisions are being made. But libraries? Literacy is FUNDAMENTAL. Free Voluntary Reading = Readers = Literate Citizenry. Many districts are choosing NOT to cut libraries this year: Santa Ana Unified, Kern High School District, El Monte Union High School District, Anaheim Union High School District, San Ramon Valley Unified, Davis Unified, South San Francisco Unified, San Francisco Unified, Fresno Unified School District, Kings Canyon Unified School District, Riverside Unified School District, Fontana Unified, Orange Unified, Napa Valley Unified, Oakley Union Elementary School District and Tamalapis Unified High School District are all to be commended for their DEDICATION to keeping school libraries open and thriving. Their students deserve it. All our students deserve it.
libladylib's picture
I now believe in Mortal sin. What are these so called "professionals" thinking? If kids can't read, they will NOT succeed.
smartimo's picture
In addition to all the reasons to keep libraries open that relate to student achievement and literacy, it is a legal requirement for districts to do so. School districts should check their Education Code section 18100 which requires districts to "provide school library services for the pupils and teachers of the district by establishing and maintaining school libraries or by contractual arrangements with another public agency." The Education Code further requires in Section 18103 that "the libraries shall be open to the use of the teachers and of the pupils of the school district during the school day." Maybe a grand jury somewhere would be interested in districts that clearly are violating state laws that have been in effect since the 1970's.
pjoehlman's picture
Smartimo makes a very good point as to the Education Code requirements. Amazingly, our California children are expected to compete for college and job slots that are increasingly dependent on the student's ability to navigate and utilize information effectively and ethically. Students are being prepared for positions that are beyond our current imagination. School libraries foster curiosity and the ability to think critically in all curricular areas. The lack of access to information and its use will be very difficult to restore "Once monies return" when collections have scattered and hardware is obsolete. This gap in our current education of students will be felt for many years to come. Thankfully, as MSlim notes, some districts in California get it.
msannette's picture
I don't know if I like the image of "libraries as nesting birds falling from their valued perches". I would rather think of libraries as being the suns that serve as energy sources powering the rest of the scholastic ecosystem: central stars of the educational universe. The energy produced propels teachers and learners forward into the unimagined future. The standards based testing regime is the parasitic tapeworm draining the lifeblood of the educational system. It is not visionary or productive. It solely exists for measuring, evaluating and assessing the present. Just like most parasites, the true effects of such narrow-minded thinking go unnoticed for a long period of time. Finally the patient weakens and succumbs to some incidental minor ailment. The whole idea of closing libraries, essential repositories of information, just shows how stupid the "most intelligent species really is". The game of survival just got a little tougher for the fittest.
friendyomi222's picture
I have no idea. The only thing I can recommend is that when you print out your paper make sure it is quick print. Also try to have color of the text be lighter. EDIT: Go to your local library or school's library. Ask a friend who has a printer to print papers out and then just go over and pick it up. jordan II kicks

via Twitter

development:  Happy Snowman Tech   /  design: