Looking for the latest stories? We're now at cironline.org

Stimulus funds aiding companies accused of fraud, pollution

Large corporations working in California have reaped tens of millions of dollars in new federal stimulus funds, despite previous pollution violations, criminal probes, and allegations of fraud, a California Watch investigation has found.

Residents in Ventura County say they are dismayed that airplane and defense giant Boeing received a $15.9 million stimulus contract for environmental monitoring at the same site near Simi Valley where the company was fined for polluting a creek with chromium, dioxin, lead and mercury. A local resident and opponent, Dawn Kowalski, called the new contract “the fox guarding the hen house.”

Watsonville-based Granite Construction received $6.4 million in stimulus contracts to work on airport runways in Salinas and Monterey, and to repair roads in San Bernadino, Riverside and Butte counties. Yet the company faces three federal probes, including a criminal investigation into whether it fraudulently overcharged the city of San Diego in the wake of the devastating 2007 wildfires.

And a major apartment owner based in Denver, AIMCO, stands to benefit from $13 million in stimulus tax credits to rehabilitate its housing complex in Los Angeles. This federal assistance comes after the company paid $3 million in 2004 to settle a lawsuit from the city of San Francisco over complaints that it operated mold and rodent-infested buildings that posed serious safety hazards. Residents continue to complain about AIMCO’s management.

To government watchdogs, these contracts and others raise concerns about the way the massive federal stimulus program is being administered. Although most major companies in America face lawsuits and regulatory action, these government reformers say a contractor’s entire history should be considered before doling out more money to the same firms.

“It is very upsetting that the government doesn't do more due diligence before it hands money out,” said Laura N. Chick, California's inspector general for stimulus funds.

Stimulus money has flowed quickly into California over the past year, moving from federal agencies to specific contractors that compete for projects, or through the state government and local agencies that have their own bidding process for distributing federal money. The process is moving so rapidly, the government may not be making the best decisions, one government watchdog said.

“I think we’re trying to spend money as quickly as possible, and at that point putting taxpayers’ money at risk,” said Scott Amey, general counsel of the Project on Government Oversight, which tracks contractor misconduct.

But one major stimulus contractor with past legal troubles, CH2M Hill, said focusing on a few isolated cases would be a misleading representation of its work. The company was awarded a $20.7 million federal stimulus contract to clean up contaminated sediment from a defunct mine near Redding in Shasta County – a contract that enabled CH2M Hill to keep as many as 21 positions that otherwise would have been eliminated.

In 2008, CH2M Hill was sued by the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power for an alleged scheme to deceive and defraud the city with spurious charges over several years. The suit was settled under undisclosed terms. The company also was fined more than $800,000 for spilling 85 gallons of radioactive waste in 2007 while cleaning up an old nuclear site in southeastern Washington, according to a report by the federal Government Accountability Office.

“We have more than 10,000 active projects all over the globe and on a rare occasion we may have an issue with an individual project,” said John Corsi, a spokesman for CH2M Hill. Corsi said both the Los Angeles and Washington projects were successful.

Clean energy project questioned

One of the biggest stimulus projects in California is a hydrogen power plant, near Bakersfield, that's getting a taxpayer infusion of $308 million.

The project, by BP and mining company Rio Tinto, is designed to generate more environmentally friendly electricity by capturing carbon dioxide from the burning of fossil fuels. The project would bury and store the emissions underground in an oil field reservoir.

In 2005, BP paid $81 million to settle lawsuits that its refinery spewed noxious fumes into the working-class city of Carson. The company has also pleaded guilty to criminal violations of environmental laws – for a 2005 explosion at BP's Texas refinery that killed 15 people and a 2006 oil spill in Alaska. This past October, federal safety officials fined BP $87 million, which the company is contesting, for failing to fix the hazards in Texas. Also last year, BP agreed to pay $179 million to resolve government findings that its Texas plant leached cancer-causing and ozone-depleting chemicals.

BP referred questions to a spokewoman for the hydrogen power plant, who spoke of the project's benefits and noted that BP and its partner will provide most of the funding. Tiffany Rau, spokeswoman for Hydrogen Energy California, said the new facility is “designed to be the cleanest solid fuel power plant in the world.” The Department of Energy’s grant to BP and Rio Tinto, she said, “further recognizes that the project owners have invested several tens of millions of dollars in the project thus far.”

Another stimulus contractor, the Computer Sciences Corp., received a $5.1 million NASA contract for technological improvements at the Ames Research Center in Silicon Valley. The project money is for equipment and has not created any jobs. In 2008, the company paid the federal government $1.4 million to settle allegations that it ran a contracting kickback scheme. A NASA spokeswoman said the agency didn't find problems with the company's past performance.

Boeing contract under fire

One stimulus contract through the Department of Energy is causing consternation in the rugged foothills above Simi Valley in Ventura County.

The toxic contamination at the Santa Susana Field Laboratory has been a painfully sore subject to locals for decades. Since the 1940s, the lab was operated by divisions of North American Aviation, which eventually became Rockwell International. It was the site of rocket engine testing and nuclear power development that led to toxins leaching into the dirt and groundwater and a partial nuclear meltdown in 1959.

Boeing acquired the aerospace divisions of Rockwell International in 1996, but community activists said Boeing has been fighting its responsibility for pollution that occurred before and after the purchase. A group of local residents sued Boeing, contending that the company caused cancer. The company settled for $30 million in 2005.

The regional water quality board fined Boeing $471,000 in 2007 for 79 pollution violations that let wastewater and storm runoff from the site ooze toxins into various creeks, flowing downstream to the Los Angeles River.

Boeing had discharged 118.5 million gallons of water laced with pollutants like chromium, lead and mercury, according to the water board. At one point, the company exceeded the allowable concentration of cancer-causing dioxin by 6,900 times. The water board said the chronic violations created a risk to public health and, given Boeing's resources and sophistication, were “exceedingly serious.”

Dan Hirsch, president of a California nuclear watchdog group, doesn’t believe Boeing should have been rewarded with federal stimulus money for environmental monitoring there. The contract for Boeing, which made $2.7 billion in profits in 2008, was not bid competitively. “How can one have federal taxpayer money going to a company that is responsible for the contamination and is resisting the cleanup?” Hirsch said.

Boeing said it has made significant progress. “Boeing is fully committed to cleaning up the site in a manner that fully protects public health and the environment,” wrote spokeswoman Kamara Sams in an e-mail to California Watch. She said Boeing, NASA and the Department of Energy are responsible for cleaning up portions of the property.

Jen Stutsman, an Energy Department spokeswoman, responded by e-mail that Boeing has the expertise to perform the work and a good track record of working with the agency. “Changing contractors would only cost the taxpayer additional money as a new contractor arrived and took over the work for Boeing,” she wrote. The project was reported to have created 11 jobs.

At the same time, Boeing is trying to overturn a California toxic cleanup law. On Nov. 13, Boeing sued in federal court to invalidate SB 990, which holds the Ventura County cleanup to especially strict standards. Boeing claims the California-mandated standards are unnecessary and the excavation required would further destroy the “ecological habitat.”

State Assemblywoman Julia Brownley, who represents nearby residents, said she's concerned that Boeing is getting stimulus money and “almost in the same breath” suing against California cleanup standards. “Something just seems not right in that picture,” she said.

Under investigation

Granite Construction picked up several stimulus contracts – which were distributed through Caltrans and various local agencies – despite being at the center of a fraud scandal in San Diego, where many residents feel the company took advantage of the city in a time of crisis.

“As a taxpayer, I would be more than a little frustrated with that, given the track record here in this city,” said Jan Rasmussen, a San Diego resident and outreach coordinator of Rancho Bernardo United, a community group that helps victims of the 2007 wildfires.

The city of San Diego sued Granite Construction and another company, A.J. Diani, in 2008 for separately allegedly overbilling for their debris removal services after the disaster. The city claimed both companies billed with “falsified records” that overestimated the amount of debris they had cleared and that the firms had inflated their costs. The lawsuit is on hold pending a criminal probe by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security.

Granite also faces two U.S. Department of Justice investigations. One targets an Oregon construction project where storm runoff dumped dirt into various creeks, possibly harming the fish population. The other focuses on allegations that a joint venture run by Granite in Minnesota failed to hire enough minority businesses as subcontractors and missrepresented those efforts.

A Granite spokesperson, Jacque Fourchy, said the company is open about its legal problems in corporate filings and disputes wrongdoing in San Diego. “It's unfortunate,” Fourchy said, “that this investigation continues to plague us because we really feel like we didn't do anything wrong.”

Apartment owners sued

The federal government has directed stimulus funds, in the form of tax credits, to create low-income housing across the state. Denver-based AIMCO – in a joint venture with the nonprofit Foundation for Affordable Housing – was offered $13 million in tax credits to help fix up its senior housing apartment complex in Los Angeles. An AIMCO spokeswoman said the company has yet to accept the stimulus tax credit and contends the project “represents the company’s continued commitment to meeting the critical need for affordable housing.”

But in the Bayview-Hunters Point neighborhood in San Francisco, residents have complained for years of slumlord conditions and bad management at the AIMCO apartment complexes. “We trust them as far as we can throw them – that's the general rule when it comes to AIMCO,” said Sara Shortt, director of the Housing Rights Committee of San Francisco, a nonprofit tenants-rights organization.

The city of San Francisco sued AIMCO, saying that the company ignored more than two dozen orders to fix scores of health and safety hazards, including stairways collapsing from dry rot as well as moldy, water-damaged ceilings and walls. Inspectors cited a blocked fire escape and lack of smoke detectors. They also found broken windows and doors and faulty plumbing. AIMCO settled the suit for $3 million in 2004.

Resident Dorothy Peterson said she was considering protesting the stimulus assistance to AIMCO. “If they really wanted to make sure that low income housing was built properly and for residents that were going to be treated like human beings, then they would not give it to an AIMCO,” she said.

But AIMCO's partner on the Los Angeles project vouches for the company. “They're huge,” said Deborrah Willard, president of the Southern California-based Foundation for Affordable Housing. “When you're huge and you own this many units, you're bound to make somebody unhappy somewhere along the line.”


This story was edited by Mark Katches and Robert Salladay. It was copy edited by William Cooley.


Comments are closed for this story.
Anonymous's picture
It would be good to know who the largest e-waste polluters are in California.
fallar's picture
Just goes to show you that the stimulus money is not being properly spent and is only going to those türkçe sünger bob izle in the know. I'm sure some good will come of it but sünger bob izle for most, it's going bakugan izle to the pockets of the çizgi film izle wealthy. bakugan izle - sünger bob izle
seo007's picture
adiyatma's picture
yes thats right
mariogames's picture
punish them and save our earth, thank god there still some people think about earth
games kids - funny games - photo hunt - saigon travel - mario games
cindyneil's picture
I agree but giving them money is not very punishing. That's our government at work. Lining the pockets of their constituents.
Cindy Signals
Forex Signals
Automated Forex Signals
tim333's picture
If they where convicted and paid fine and fixed problem that would be ok. If they have not fixed anything they should not get any money or contracts till they do.
nlnforever's picture
Save our earth please, no tolerance in this issue WebGameNow Flash Game - Download Games
tom0571's picture
I am accomplishing analysis plan in the acreage of solar energy. I charge digital abstracts of all-around solar radiation of Nepal copper clad aluminum, power cable, speaker cable If accessible amuse accommodate us for added analysis or informations.
octavdiam's picture
There is no doubt we must use a free energy generator anti polution using a magnet motor especially in some zones like Realtor San Francisco Peninsula after some researches of real estate statistics news
mybeijia's picture
Still, fake Louis Vuitton there are some things worth mentioning about the louis vuitton purse nonetheless. The style, functionality and style of the louis vuitton purses are above the average. And the color of the handle and the body of the bag just go well with each other and it is beyond imagination.
removalists4u's picture
I am just new to your blog and just spent about 1 hour and 30 minutes lurking and reading.I think I will frequent your blog from now on after going through some of your posts.I will definitely learn a lot from them. collection agencies
hacker's picture
Best Double Stroller is the number one place online to find the hottest deals on double strollers! Our goal is to locate all of the top rated double strollers and bring them to you at the best prices! best double stroller
airwolfe777's picture
Learn How to Start a Limousine Business as a great source of income!
kelly's picture
They cover all significant venues of the state and they have been specially churned to suit all categories of visitors ranging from first-timers to regular-ones. The budget travel packages offered by us offer myriad duration options ranging from 1 night stay to 10 nights stay. kerala travel
Steven2's picture
It's really appalling to hear that these companies who have reaped tens of millions of dollars in new federal stimulus funds have the audacity to commit these crimes in California. It appears that the oversight has been lacking, and taxpayers are picking up the costs. wow cd-key
cocoom's picture
The two of us truly enjoyed your article. It seems like you've put a lot of effort into your article and the public need much more of these on the Net these days. I don't real have a marvelous deal to say in retort, I just wanted to comment to tell well done. good post. i never think of that.
Regards,Jason Smith Researcher of celebrity phone numbers
removalists4u's picture
Match fixing has no longer been a secret in the field of football, there are some revealed & many left unrealized. Fixed matches are the golden chance to make big profit, therefore we named it the Golden Tips, but many are left out from the chance to gain this edge. football betting tips
katieprice's picture
Looking for party rentals in San Diego? Carnival Entertainment's Party Rental World is your premier party rentals source for kids' birthday parties, weddings, school carnivals, street fairs, and company picnics in San Diego. San Diego Party Rentals
comehades's picture
Louis Vuitton will soon begin to focus on various lv bags types of metal materials used in hard box external design, such as copper, zinc and aluminum. Copper special hard case to tropical areas mainly for travelers or explorers, louis vuitton backpack compression and strong. Junction sealing rubber band can be pest control and moisture.
raycruz182's picture
At the very start, I’d prefer to state thanks to you for this informative article. Secondly, I had prefer to wonder wheresoever I can learn a lot more data pertaining your post. I arrived here through Ask and can't get any other corresponding web internet sites along this matter. How do I sign for your web blog? I had prefer to stick to your updates as they come along! I had a query to question but I forgotten what it absolutely was... anyway, thank you very much. Sincerely, Ray Cruz Author of how to cook beef tenderloin
hacker's picture
What sets Affinity apart from other day trading education firms is our commitment to your success. Not only do we train and support you to be a professional in day trading, scalp trading, swing trading and forex trading, we also provide you with the necessary capital in which to trade with. Day Trading Education
cindyneil's picture
Just goes to show you that the stimulus money is not being properly spent and is only going to those in the know. I'm sure some good will come of it but for most, it's going to the pockets of the wealthy.

Cindy Signals
Forex Signals
Automated Forex Signals

removalists4u's picture
Thank you for this step by step instruction. Great ideas and tips. I’ve always had trouble finding a free place to blatantly advertise my products and services so I made one. pandora jewellery
Cape Coral Real Estate's picture
Shame to those companies who committed fraud with the stimulus money. They should probably relocate themselves by buying some Cape Coral Real Estate with that money instead :-)
noucktourno's picture
It's really appalling to hear that these companies who have reaped tens of millions of dollars in new federal stimulus funds have the audacity to commit these crimes in California. It appears that buy steroids the oversight has been lacking, and taxpayers are picking up the costs.
scented _rocks's picture
Let me take my muffler off my car, so I can cash in also crystal potpourri | scented crystals | scented rocks
humza's picture
I think you did excellent in this post, there are more need of such accountability in such cases.
louisvuittonhandbags's picture
That is some inspirational stuff. Never knew that opinions could be this varied. Thanks for all the enthusiasm to offer such helpful information here.
noucktourno's picture
There are some very great sources here and thank you for being so kind to post them here. So we can read them and give our opinion on subject. Douglas Mallette Author: Turning Point ( digi sport live ) Available NOW @ the Blog
comemyblog's picture
After the show,The Startup Of Louis Vuitton GQ.com put "Super avant-garde (Super avant-garde)" did not hesitate to praise presented to him. But make sure everyone is satisfied and the last sets of non-zipper without "tricks" the navy 2 button suit,Louis Vuitton Fashion MB M93224 perfectly demonstrates the designer's self-confidence and taste.
comemyblog's picture
. For example, LV wallet Duijiang number of caps required for the 87,12,99,55,Louis Vuitton Hong Kong consumers no matter what hand the number of caps you can participate in only one LV wallet spike,Cheap Louis Vuitton Bag but would like to receive Collect a prize Zexu specified
munnar's picture
The duration is decided on what the visitors desire to get out of their visit to the state and also on the budget at disposal. If there is a package that attempts a blend of the mist and tea plantations of DARJEELING with DARJEELING TOUR PACKAGES.
ricky2's picture
This shows that the stimulus fund is not being properly spent and is only going to those who are well connected. We need more transparency in the government. burning crusade key
estar's picture
urselves strangely ugg cardy boots drawn toward the boots
noucktourno's picture
If you agreed to the plan to have strangers in Washington spend your money for you, then you really have no right to complain. Next time, keep it in hand and give to Greenpeace or a soup kitchen, or a brothel if that's your thing. But if you trusted DC to do the right thing with YOUR dough, then zip it. Thanks, Douglas M, CEO Rezultate live
wr4455's picture
Thanks for the interesting post. This is just a sample of how improperly our taxes are being used for all the wasted stimulus spending. It is going to come back to bite us bad. Greg Capra Mastertrader.com
selina's picture
“When you're huge and you own this many units, you're bound to make somebody unhappy somewhere along the line.” It is quite interesting to learn about these stimulus funds aiding companies fined for pollution accused of fraud. The discussion offers a fair idea of the functioning of the system in this regard. thanks for sharing the idea. mike geary
jackiboa's picture
I am looking forward for your next post, I will try to get the hang of it! Masters Degree Phd Degree Postgraduate Degree
jackiboa's picture
I'm the same way, I do my best to remain neutral. It's hard, if you communicate with the person the other person dislikes, then you fall out of favor with them! I simple can't dislike a person, just because someone else does, I just can't. Undergraduate Degree University Degree
katieprice's picture
This is my first time i visit here. I found so many entertaining stuff in your blog, especially its discussion. car buying
noucktourno's picture
Well, the post is in reality the freshest on this noteworthy topic. I harmonize with your conclusions and will thirstily look forward to your future updates. Saying thanks will not just be sufficient, for the exceptional about generic viagra lucidity in your writing...
adiel_m's picture
I agree but giving them money is not very punishing. That's our government at work.מילון עברי אנגלי קידום בגוגל להיות ראשון Lining the pockets of their constituent שמלות כלה אנטי וירוס
macbookmed's picture
Don't really agree with everything that you said but at least we can agree on something universal in this topic Gas Electric Range
submissionjobz's picture
I totally agreed with you.....Stock Market News
bill-ts-57's picture
You should see what Italy is in this metter
Jibran's picture
Don't really agree with everything that you said but at least we can agree on something universal in this topic joomla web hosting
kevin22's picture
I agree that companies that have been convicted should not be able to get the money until they fix the problem. The ones that have not be found guilty yet should have some of the money held back until they are cleared or fix any problems. I know your inocent untill proven so i guess you can not stop those companies from getting the money.
tufty's picture
This shouldn't surprise any of us as the stimulus seems out of control and has become a free for all. Many people have benefited when they shouldn't have as there is no proper accounting nor regulation.
Hosting plans's picture
Any stimulus payments need to have controls in place to prevent corruption, otherwise funds will be misused and will not generate any effects on economy.
cindycheng's picture
The disadvantage currently is still inside the supply network. The number of pellet heating systems has increased significantly in recent years. Regrettably, the utilities have failed to grow the distribution network. Large quantities of the wood pellets are required, so it was temporarily congested. However, if your wood pellets are for residence use,
Double Strollers's picture
I hate to see good money wasted, especially when that money has been pledged to help the country as a whole

via Twitter

© 2013 California Watch   /  development:  Happy Snowman Tech   /  design: